Professor sen is uniquely qualified to accept the challenge, and i thank him for doing so. This book is an excellent introduction for those interested in crosscultural studies in general and for those who struggle to understand confucianism in. Contesting national identities and cultural representations in asia 2000. Advocates of asian values typically claimed that the rapid development of many east asian economies in the postworld war ii. The effect of confucian values on support for democracy and human rights in taiwan joel s.
Asian values and communitarian democracy, paper presented at the international workshop on deliberating. Christopher soper abstract recent years have seen a great deal of interest in the extent to which asian values, or confucian ideology, inhibit a countrys acceptance of liberaldemocratic values. Too often, this kind of debate involves recovering obscure and. Essays on the individual in neo confucian thought cup, 1991 the trouble with confucianism, harvard up, 1991 eastern canons. Communitarianism stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Human rights and asian values carnegie council for. Its proponents advocate a view of society that is always hierarchical and tends to stem from emphasising the interdependence and social nature of human beings. Pdf modern confucianism and the concept of asian values. With his profound and broad knowledge of confucianism, he vividly describes a variety of confucian values and programs that could nurture a modern liberalism. The chapter also examines how the nonnative system gradually evolved and took root in a land dominated by asian values, where the government or the ruler had customarily been pronounced as the peoples parent, and the fundamental notions of the rule of law, human rights, independent judiciary, separation of powers, equality, and the. The effect of confucian values on support for democracy. There are three main explanatory perspectives of how confucianism interacts with. A confucian perspective on human rights for contemporary china. The evolving debates about values in asia randall peerenboom from its humble and legally fragile beginnings, the international human rights movement has developed into a potent political force capable of influencing a nations domestic politics.
A confucian communitarian perspective wingtsit chan memorial. In short, proponents of the asian values case held that human rights, in particular civil and political rights, were culturally specific and could not be applied universally. The work of csos with regards to the aichr and ahrd are discussed in detail in section 5. A confucian communitarian perspective has 2 available editions to buy at half price books marketplace. The singaporean patriarch lee kuan yew popularized the argument that asian values derived from confucian cultural traditions are inconsistent with the development of democracy in east asia. The success of these countries, in relation to the downturn of western economies, and the friction which has arisen over trade protectionism, economic conditionality, democracy and human rights have made the asian values debate more than just an intellectual exercise. Too often, this kind of debate involves recovering obscure and longforgotten references. To read the full introduction, download the pdf at the bottom of this. The success of these countries, in relation to the downturn of western economies, and the friction which has arisen over trade protectionism, economic conditionality, democracy and human rights have made the asian values debate more than just an intellectual. Kennedy, tae wan kim, alan strudler skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The defense of authoritarianism in asia on grounds of the special nature of asian values calls for historical scrutiny, to which i. Sep 30, 1998 asian values is a concept advanced by some authoritarian regimes to differentiate an asian model of development, supposedly based on confucianism, from a western model identified with individualism, liberal democracy, and human rights. The defense of authoritarianism in asia on grounds of the special nature of asian values calls for historical scrutiny, to which i shall presently turn.
Harvard university press, 1998, 34 in which he points out that the identification of the asian model of development with confucianism is an idea that could only have come from singapore itself. It aimed to use commonalities for example, the principle of collectivism to unify people for their economic and social good and to create a panasian. The lessons that we can learn from this debate will be discussed in the final part, together with a short conclusion. Toward an aristotelian conception of the public sphere. Asian values and human rights is an attempt to present and defend an interpretation of confucianism that may be relevant for confucian influenced societies in east asia, especially china too often, this kind of debate involves recovering obscure and longforgotten references, and proving that asian societies profess this or that. Asian values debateor, what everybody needed to know about asian values that social scientists failed to point out, sojourn. Bell, eds, the east asian challenge for human rights, pp. Jul 26, 2015 afroasian culturetraditions,values and tourist spots of japan. Pdf authority orientations and democratic attitudes. In this paper, the author argues that although it is a new trend of human rights discourse and a contribution to the evolution of human rights theories, the emergence of the asian values perspective is a great challenge to universal human rights and international human rights regimes. A confucian communitarian perspective cambridge, ma. Confucian ethics and the spirit of capitalism in korea.
The 1990s saw the rise of what came to be known as asian values in the global human rights debate. Professor sens chosen topic, human rights and asian values, challenges us on philosophic, economic, and cultural grounds. Approaches to the asian classics cup, 1990 message of the mind in neoconfucianism cup, 1989. Essays on the individual in neo confucian thought cup, 1991 the trouble with confucianism.
Confucianism, asian values, and human rights bibliography. Some authoritarian leaders in asia have blamed human rights and democracy. Asian values and human rights is an attempt to present and defend an interpretation of confucianism that may be relevant for confucianinfluenced societies in east asia, especially china. Confucianism and reflexive modernity bringing community. This study tested arguments in the largely anecdotal debate over the existence of asian values in asian journalism. In all four of the lecture series above, huang tsunghsi 16101695, the neo confucian scholar whose life spanned three and a half decades of the.
The states vision, known formally as our shared values, consists of communitarian values that reflect the official ideology of multiculturalism. Afroasian culturetraditions,values and tourist spots of. The problem of human rights is not one of individualistic west versus communitarian asia. While disputing the politicians appropriation of values. Modern confucianism and the concept of asian values. This debate fundamentally questions our knowledge of human rights and how such an understanding came to be. Highlighting the philosophical development of confucianism as well as the chinese historical experience with community organization, constitutionalism, education, and womens rights, wm. Excerpt from president joel rosenthals introduction. The bangkok declaration adopted by asian governments in april 1993 stakes out a distinctively asian point of view on issues of human rights. Asian values, therefore, should not become an excuse for asian politicians to sanction violation of basic human rights such as torture of political prisoners or oppression of free speech patten, 1996. Asian values, confucian tradition and human rights. May 17, 2009 in this paper, the author argues that although it is a new trend of human rights discourse and a contribution to the evolution of human rights theories, the emergence of the asian values perspective is a great challenge to universal human rights and international human rights regimes. Opponents have argued that this view can lead to the advocating of double standards to justify mass violations of human rights. Discourse on human rights advocacy in southeast asia literature on human rights in southeast asia in general is of relatively.
Theodore and a great selection of similar new, used and collectible books available now at great prices. The debate on asian values and democracy the debate on asian values is. The author makes a sharp confrontation with the paradigm of asian value debate led by lee kwanyew and defends a balance between individual empowerment and flourishing community for human rights, basically in line with juergen habermas, but in the context of global risk society, particularly from an enlightened perspective of confucianism. Our understanding of human rights has, for the most part, taken shape as part of a larger debate between the western claims to universality and cultural relativism. The effect of confucian values on support for democracy and. Western values, and that the claims of human rights in the areas of political and civil liberties are, therefore, less relevant in asia than in the west. In fact it is highly, perhaps irredeemably, politicized. Drawing on the thoughts of key confucian thinkers and aspects of chinese history, wm. Chan, joseph 1999, a confucian perspective on human rights for contemporary china, in joanne r. A confucian communitarian approach volume 26 issue 4 jessica a. The term asian values is a political ideology that arose in the 1990s, which defined elements of society, culture, and history common to the nations of southeast asia and east asia. Asian values and human rights is an attempt to present and defend an interpretation of confucianism that may be relevant for confucian influenced societies in east asia, this only serves to reinforce preexisting political viewpoints. Since the horrific tiananmen square massacre in 1989, the debate on human rights in china has raged on with increasing volume and shifting context, but little real progress.
Asian values is a concept advanced by some authoritarian regimes to differentiate an asian model of development, supposedly based on confucianism, from a western model identified with individualism, liberal democracy, and human rights. The asian values argument is largely an expression of cultural relativism. An empirical study of mainland china, taiwan and hong kong introduction the overthrow of the portuguese dictatorship in 1974 triggered the third wordwide wave. This paper points out that underpinning the shared values are pejorative interpretations of individual rights and. Do african values exist, and can they, at least in part, be attributable to africas poor human rights record. News stories uploaded to 10 asian online newspapers were content analyzed for the prevalence of harmony and supportiveness, which the literature suggests as key asian values.
1377 624 1122 193 898 137 548 1584 105 1371 97 768 1269 522 934 1182 1456 1485 501 694 96 1175 1159 771 1182 298 1424 879 104 325 854 1376 872 574